Frontkrieg Blog Play free →
Language: AR EN RU UK

Operation Alberich 1917: How Germany Retreated to the Hindenburg Line and Scorched the Land

Operation Alberich was the German strategic withdrawal on the Western Front between 9 February and 20 March 1917, when the army pulled back about 40 km from the Bapaume and Noyon salients to a new, shorter and stronger position - the Hindenburg Line (Siegfriedstellung). The retreat shortened the front by roughly 40 km, freed 13 to 14 divisions for the German reserve and left behind a wasteland of about 1,500 square kilometres, where villages, roads, railways and wells had been destroyed. Historians call it one of the shrewdest defensive operations of the war - and also a propaganda disaster for Germany. It is a textbook case of a lesson every strategy player learns sooner or later: sometimes the strongest move is to give up ground, save your troops and make the attacker start from scratch.

This article explains why Germany decided to retreat, how the withdrawal was carried out, why the Allies were caught off guard, and what the operation teaches you in Frontkrieg. You can test the ideas in the game lobby - a new match starts every day.

Operation Alberich in numbers

  • Dates: 9 February - 20 March 1917; the main withdrawal took place on 16-20 March.
  • Place: northern France, between Arras, Saint-Quentin and Noyon - the Bapaume and Noyon salients left after the Battle of the Somme.
  • Front shortened: about 40 km (25 miles); some sources give 40-45 km.
  • Troops saved: 13 to 14 fewer divisions were needed to hold the line, which became a fresh strategic reserve.
  • Balance of forces: the German army in the west had 154 divisions against about 190 Allied divisions.
  • Land laid waste: about 1,500 square kilometres (580 square miles).
  • Civilians: about 125,000 able-bodied French civilians were taken to work elsewhere in occupied France.
  • Result: a German success - the line was shortened and the Allied spring plans were disrupted.

Why Germany decided to retreat

By the end of the Somme battle the German army was exhausted. In August 1916 Paul von Hindenburg and Erich Ludendorff took over the Supreme Army Command from Erich von Falkenhayn, and soon afterwards they ordered a new defensive line to be built east of the Somme front, from Arras to Laon. The problem was manpower: even with reinforcements from the Eastern Front the Germans in the west had only 154 divisions against about 190 on the Allied side.

The Hindenburg Line offered a way out. It was built in depth, behind wide belts of barbed wire and studded with machine-gun nests, and in many sectors its positions sat on reverse slopes so that enemy artillery could not easily see them. A shorter front meant that fewer troops could hold more ground. The Germans also expected that the Allies would have to rebuild all their roads and railways before attacking the new line, and every day of delay gave the U-boat campaign - resumed on 1 February 1917 - more time to work.

The decision was not easy. Ludendorff hesitated until the last moment because a retreat could damage the morale of soldiers and civilians. General Fritz von Below, who commanded the 1st Army on the Somme, opposed it, and Crown Prince Rupprecht of Bavaria preferred a deeper withdrawal to a line through Lille and Cambrai. The commander of the XIV Reserve Corps reported that morale was low and that some positions on the Ancre were no more than flooded shell holes. On 4 February 1917 Kaiser Wilhelm II ordered the intervening ground to be devastated and the retirement to begin on 9 February.

How the retreat was carried out

9-22 February: preparation and the first step back

Alberich began in the area that was to be abandoned. Railways and roads were dug up, trees were felled, wells were polluted, towns and villages were demolished, and many mines and booby traps were planted. On 22 February the 1st Army withdrew about 4.8 km on a front of roughly 24 km to an intermediate position. A second step back came on 11 March, during a British preparatory bombardment, and the British did not notice it until the night of 12-13 March.

16-20 March: the main withdrawal

The final demolitions began on 16 March, and over the next five days the German army fell back about 40 km, giving up the Noyon salient completely. Rearguards of machine gunners covered the retreat, and the roads behind them were cratered with mines. One estimate quoted in the historical literature says the Germans gave up more French territory than the Allies had won between September 1914 and the start of the operation.

The scorched earth

The destruction was deliberate and systematic. Rupprecht opposed turning the Noyon salient into a wasteland because of the damage to the prestige of the German Empire and the effect on the discipline of his own troops; he even thought of resigning, but stayed for fear of suggesting a rift between Bavaria and the rest of Germany. Children, mothers and the elderly were left behind with minimal rations. This is why the operation is remembered as a propaganda disaster as well as a military success.

Why the Allies were caught off guard

The Allies did see something coming. On 9 November 1916 a formation of eight photographic reconnaissance aircraft with eight escorts reported a new line of defences from Bourlon Wood to Quéant and Bullecourt. Yet frequent bad flying weather over the winter and the habit of the Germans of building new lines behind old ones led British intelligence to misread the signs; only by mid-January 1917 did it conclude that a new line was being built from Arras to Laon. More on the intelligence war is in WW1 intelligence and codebreaking and WW1 aviation.

When the retreat came, the pursuit was slow. British patrols found German outposts empty, but roads were wrecked, bridges blown and the Germans fell back on prepared positions behind machine-gun rearguards. The British Third and Fifth Armies took Bapaume on 17 March and Péronne on 18 March, but they had to rebuild their communications before they could attack the new line.

The timing mattered most. The extra divisions released by Alberich were assembled to meet the Franco-British Nivelle Offensive on the Aisne, whose preparations were barely concealed. When it began in April 1917, the French met a stronger defence than planned, and the failure helped to trigger the army revolt described in WW1 mutinies and desertion. The same month the Canadians took the ridge described in Battle of Vimy Ridge 1917.

Success or disaster?

Militarily, Alberich was a success: the front was shorter, the reserves were stronger and the Allied plans for the spring of 1917 were seriously disrupted. Politically, it was costly - the scorched-earth policy damaged Germany's reputation abroad. The Hindenburg Line itself did not last for ever. British tanks broke into it at Cambrai in November 1917 (see Battle of Cambrai 1917), and in the autumn of 1918 the Allies broke through it for good during the Hundred Days Offensive. For the wider picture of the stalemate it was meant to solve, read trench warfare in World War 1.

What Alberich teaches in Frontkrieg

  • A shorter front is easier to hold. Anchor your flanks on seas, mountains or neutral states and give up the bulges that tie down troops for nothing. The principle is explained in the defensive tactics guide.
  • Trade space for what brings money. Defend your capital, ports and factory cities rather than the whole perimeter. A lost border province is annoying; a lost economic hub can collapse your budget in a single game day.
  • Make the attacker pay in time. Armies move at only 0.35 of normal speed on enemy territory, so every province you leave costs the pursuer hours. See the troop movement guide.
  • Build a strongpoint in depth. A fortress has up to 5 levels, each level holding 400 HP, and it cuts damage to the defending troops by 30% to 90%. A fortress of level 3 or higher also hides the size of its garrison.
  • Scout the rear. The British misread the signs; in the game a balloon identifies enemies at 400 units and senses movement out to 720, a fighter sees 200 and infantry only 90. Read the reconnaissance and fog of war guide.
  • Hit the enemy's rear. Railways have 250 HP, and a railway gun deals 15 points per round from 340 distance units - see how to destroy enemy buildings.

Frontkrieg is a free browser strategy about World War 1 with no pay-to-win: a map of 4,800 provinces, up to 500 players and 70 AI nations. Open the lobby, shorten your front - and see whether you have the nerve to give up ground on purpose.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Germans retreat to the Hindenburg Line?

Because they were short of troops: 154 divisions in the west against about 190 Allied ones. A shorter front on a stronger, deeper position freed 13 to 14 divisions and forced the Allies to rebuild their communications before attacking.

Was Operation Alberich successful?

Militarily yes: the front was shortened by about 40 km, the reserves grew and the Allied spring plans were disrupted. Politically it was a propaganda setback for Germany because of the scorched-earth policy.

Why was it called Alberich?

The name comes from Alberich, the chief of the dwarfs (Nibelungs) in Wagner's opera cycle "Der Ring des Nibelungen". The Hindenburg Line itself was called Siegfriedstellung by the Germans, and other sections carried names from the same German epic.

Was the Hindenburg Line ever broken?

Yes. British tanks broke into it at Cambrai in November 1917, and in September-October 1918 the Allies broke through it during the Hundred Days Offensive. The 2019 film "1917" is set in April 1917, against the background of this very retreat.

From a salient to a straight line

Alberich shows that retreat can be a form of attack on the enemy's plans: Germany gave up ground, saved divisions and spoiled the Allied spring offensives. More history and strategy guides are in the blog.

Source: Operation Alberich - Wikipedia

Keep reading

Try Frontkrieg right now

A free real-time WW1 grand strategy. Command an empire on a live 1914 map of Europe against hundreds of players.

Play free →