Battle of Cambrai 1917: The First Massed Tank Attack and the German Counterattack
The Battle of Cambrai (20 November - 7 December 1917) was the first massed tank attack in history: 476 British tanks, 378 of them fighting machines, broke the German Hindenburg Line without days of preliminary bombardment and advanced about 8 km in a single day. The breakthrough could not be held, though - a German counterattack on 30 November won back most of the ground, and both sides lost roughly 45,000 men. Cambrai proved that tanks win only in combination with infantry, artillery and aircraft, and that same principle drives Frontkrieg.
This article is for readers who want a short, accurate answer to what happened at Cambrai, how it differs from the Somme or Passchendaele, and what its lessons mean for strategy.
The Battle of Cambrai 1917 in numbers
- Dates: 20 November - 7 December 1917, 18 days.
- Sides: the British Third Army under General Julian Byng against the German Second Army.
- Tanks: 476 machines, 378 of them combat tanks; the Tank Corps was led by Hugh Elles, and the plan owed much to J. F. C. Fuller.
- Zero hour: 06:20 on 20 November.
- First-day advance: up to 8 km (about 5 miles) - unheard of on the Western Front.
- Tank losses: around 180 machines over the whole operation, many to breakdowns and ditching.
- Casualties: estimates range from 40,000 to 45,000 per side; about 45,000 is the figure most often quoted.
Why the British attacked this way
By autumn 1917 British commanders had bitter experience of the Somme and Passchendaele: weeks of bombardment turned the ground into a swamp and warned the enemy of the blow. The ground at Cambrai suited tanks - firm chalk soil, hardly any shell craters. So the idea was to do something different: strike by surprise.
The Hindenburg Line had deep trenches and thick wire. To cross the trenches, tanks carried fascines on their roofs - huge bundles of brushwood dropped into the ditch so the tank could roll over it. It was a simple engineering trick, and it delivered the speed.
20 November: artillery without a warning
The main novelty was dropping the long preparatory bombardment. The guns opened fire at the same moment the tanks moved, using calculated "predicted fire" without prior ranging, so the Germans had no time to bring up reserves. Infantry followed the tanks, and smoke screens covered the flanks. Royal Flying Corps aircraft strafed German positions at low level - the role of the air war is a story of its own.
The effect was striking: within hours the British crossed several trench lines and took thousands of prisoners. In Britain, church bells rang in celebration for the first time in the war.
Where it went wrong: Flesquieres and a lack of reserves
The plan did not work everywhere. Near Flesquieres German gunners knocked out several tanks at point-blank range while the infantry lagged behind the armor. The British also lacked reserves to exploit the success: cavalry could not be sent through the gap, and after the first day many tanks were exhausted, broken down or stuck. Within four days the advance stalled.
30 November: the German counterattack
Germany struck back in a way few expected. On 30 November, after a short but intense bombardment and attacks by ground-attack aircraft, German storm detachments infiltrated between British positions, bypassing strongpoints. Within days a large part of the captured ground was lost, and the battle ended on 7 December. Infiltration tactics went far beyond Cambrai: the same principles underpinned the German Spring Offensive of 1918.
Why Cambrai matters even without a victory
Cambrai was not a strategic success but a technological and tactical turning point. It proved three things:
- tanks can crack even a strong defense if used by surprise and in mass;
- without infantry, artillery, aircraft and reserves, a breakthrough cannot be exploited;
- a defense with no reserves for a counterattack loses even after the breakthrough.
Those lessons shaped the doctrines of the following decades. For the history of the machines themselves, see our article on WW1 tanks, and for how the war froze in the mud, read about trench warfare.
Cambrai's lessons in Frontkrieg
In Frontkrieg - a free browser grand strategy game about the First World War with no pay-to-win - the logic of Cambrai applies directly. A tank is an expensive strike unit: it costs 25,000 money, 200 iron and 150 oil, takes 14 hours to build at a level 2 factory, and has 140 HP, attack 30 and speed 0.8 against 0.5 for infantry. The heavy tank (200 HP, attack 45, defense 50) costs 40,000 money, 350 iron and 250 oil.
How to carry the 1917 experience into a match:
- Strike with a combined stack. Tanks break the defense, infantry holds what is captured, artillery supports. All unit types and counters are covered in the unit types guide.
- Keep a reserve. A breakthrough without reserves is Cambrai on 20 November: you take ground but cannot hold it. Keep part of your armies back to repel a counterattack.
- Watch your oil. Every tank burns 7 money and 2 oil per game day, so fuel stocks decide whether your armored fist keeps moving.
- Never assume the win is final. The storm detachments of 30 November are a reminder: an enemy you pushed back will return at a weak flank.
The game offers up to 500 players and 70 AI nations across 4,800 provinces, and a new match starts every day - a chance to see whether you can hold a breakthrough better than the generals of 1917. Jump into the lobby and try it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who won the Battle of Cambrai?
Neither side won decisively. The British showed what massed tanks could do and kept part of the captured ground, but the German counterattack of 30 November won back most of what was lost. Historians usually describe the result as a draw of huge tactical importance.
How many people died at Cambrai?
The exact figures are disputed. Estimates put total casualties (killed, wounded and captured) at 40,000 to 45,000 per side, with about 45,000 most often cited.
How many tanks fought at Cambrai?
The British committed 476 tanks, of which 378 were fighting machines; the rest were support vehicles for signals, supply and clearing paths. Around 180 tanks were lost over the whole operation.
Was Cambrai the first tank battle in history?
It was the first massed tank attack, but not the first use of tanks (they debuted at the Somme on 15 September 1916) and not the first tank-versus-tank battle (that was Villers-Bretonneux on 24 April 1918).
From Cambrai to your front line
Cambrai is the moment the tank stopped being a curiosity and became a breakthrough tool. In Frontkrieg you can walk that road in a single match: build up industry, stockpile iron and oil, crack the front line - and do not forget the reserve. More guides and history breakdowns are in the blog.